Images Research Events Premium Services Media Kit Network Map E-mail Offers Vendor Solutions Webcasts
Search EarthWeb Network

& save on:
Compare Prices:

Be a Commerce Partner
Cheap Airline Tickets
Tech Jobs
Auto Insurance Quote
Car Insurance Quotes
Promotional Items
Phone Systems
Corporate Gifts
Web Hosting
Promotional Pen Items
Home Networking
Online Booking Hotels
Online Degrees
Cheap Plasma TVs

IT Management : Columns : Executive Tech: Can We Restore Reliability to E-Mail?

Symantec Data Management Solutions
Whitepaper: The Benefit of Continuous Data Protection
Data volume continues to grow at nearly 40% to 50% each year, making back up of mission critical data very difficult. For any organization looking to manage data growth, improve reliability, and speed data recovery, continuous data protection provides the avenue to address the challenges in a method that will improve overall data protection without weighing down IT with costly solutions.
Register Now to Download.
Whitepaper: Breaking Through the Dissimilar Hardware Restore Challenge
This paper discusses recovery to virtual computer environments, hardware migration strategies, hardware repurposing for optimal resource utilization, meeting recovery time objectives, and increasing disaster tolerance.
Register Now to Download.
Whitepaper: Converging System and Data Protection
From resilience against threats to efficient restoration of normal operations, Symantec can help keep your business up, running, and growing—no matter what happens.
Register Now to Download.
Webcast: Symantec Brings Disk-based Data Protection and Advanced System Recovery Together
Symantec Backup Exec™ and Symantec LiveState Recovery™ allow rapid and easy backup and recovery of virtually any Windows data and Windows system.
Join us for an informative Webcast to learn how to:
  • Create backups and restore to specific system recovery points
  • Maintain data availability and minimize server downtime
  • Eliminate backup windows, improving increased system reliability
  • Dramatically minimize downtime by rapidly recovering entire systems to dissimilar hardware platforms or even to virtual environments
Register Now to Watch.

Related Articles
Don't Count On Your E-Mail Being Delivered
Readers Debate Election Fraud Allegations
Measuring Search Engine Optimization
How Eyetools Finds Flaws In Your Pages
Are Your Visitors Seeing What You Think?
- ITSMWatch Newsletter -
IT Focus
Wireless in the Enterprise

Wireless technology continues to make great inroads into networks. But IT pros still must contend with a number of issues such as security, access and integration.

Ready? Set. Go!

Mobile Workers Never Looked So Thin

The Incredible Hidden Wireless Connection

Product Watch
Reload - Backup Platform for GroupWise Features Single Message Restore
KnowledgeTree - Document Management Platform with Workflow and Metadata Searching
Interop Secure Shell - SSH and SFTP Server/Clients for Windows w/SFU, SUA
SiteAssure - Anti-Phishing and Two-Factor Authentication Platform
SenSage - Clusterable Infrastructure for the Collection, Analysis of System Events

more products >>

Datamation Definitions
data mining
grid computing
network appliance
FREE Tech Newsletters

Microsoft Training Resources: Regulatory Compliance. Get the guidance, tools, and product enhancements you and your organization need to better comply with regulatory requirements.

Can We Restore Reliability to E-Mail?
April 26, 2005
By Brian Livingston

Brian Livingston I wrote in this space last week that e-mail is continuing to become more and more unreliable as a way for companies to reach consumers who sign up on notification lists.

According to a new study I cited by Pivotal Veracity, an e-mail deliverability consulting service, an average of 15% of the permission-based (opt-in) e-mail messages from the firm's clients were bounced or deleted by Internet service providers. Another 7% of the messages were incorrectly routed to a "spam" or "bulk" folder by ISPs. Different ISPs score anywhere from a low of 2.6% of such messages wrongly bounced or deleted (Yahoo) to a high of 53.4% incorrectly labeled as spam (Google Mail).

In another study, which won't be released until May, the consulting firm subscribed to the e-mail lists of more than 100 major corporations. One or more e-mail messages from 37% of the studied companies were misrouted to a spam or bulk folder, according to Pivotal Veracity's president, Deirdre Baird.

ISPs, of course, are simply trying to keep objectionable spam from reaching their end users. Unfortunately, the latest figures indicate that too many ISPs are throwing out good mail with the bad.

I received several responses to my column. The most interesting was from Suresh Ramasubramanian, the manager of security and antispam operations for Outblaze Limited, a respected e-mail service provider. Here's what he had to say.

Surveying The Field

"We are a messaging systems hosting provider based out of HKG [Hong Kong]," Suresh writes, "and we host email and spam filtering for 3 to 4 domains that were surveyed/referenced in your article." Three of the domains Outblaze hosts are, Lycos and

Pivotal Veracity had shown that 18.8%, 18.6%, and 8.5% of the permission-based e-mail messages sent to these three ISPs, respectively, were "Opt-In Mail Missing." Since Outblaze handles the spam filtering for all of these domains, the figures should have been identical instead of varying, Suresh said.

Fortunately, there's a simple answer to this. "Opt-In Mail Missing," as the column described it, represents opt-in e-mails that were bounced or deleted by the ISPs. E-mails that had been filtered into a spam folder by the ISPs were in a separate category called "Opt-In Mail Misrouted to Spam Folder."

That category, according to Pivotal Veracity's figures, showed that all three of the ISPs handled by Outblaze had a perfect record of spam filtering. You can't get a better score than 0.0% of opt-in e-mails misrouted, as these companies scored in the consulting firm's study.

Like several other ISPs in the study, these three providers seem to do a good job of recognizing that opt-in e-mails are not spam — now all they have to do is work on those bounces.

Let A Thousand Studies Bloom

Suresh also pointed out that more than one company studies the current collapse of e-mail reliability.

"There's more than one survey out there that measures deliverability," Suresh writes. "Besides Pivotal Veracity (whose survey gave you the data points for this article), there are Return Path, Lyris, etc."

I reported in this space on April 19, 2004, and Sept. 14, 2004, about the reliability studies published by Return Path, a provider that recently acquired Bonded Sender, an e-mail reputation service.

At the time of those earlier columns, Return Path said opt-in e-mails that were deleted, bounced or misrouted as spam by 16 top ISPs totaled almost 19% of the permission-based mail.

If that weren't bad enough, Return Path's latest figures, which cover all of 2004, show that the top ISPs are now misrouting 22% of the legitimate mail the consulting group monitors. That's about 3 percentage points worse than a year earlier. Interestingly, 22% is the same percentage Pivotal Veracity currently cites (15% of opt-in e-mails go missing, while another 7% are received but shunted to a spam folder).

As for Lyris, an e-mail marketing and publishing service, its own report makes pretty much the same points as the others, although the figures are slightly lower. The company's latest study, covering the first quarter of 2005, says more than 12% of permission-based e-mails are sent astray by 29 major U.S. ISPs. That includes 3.4% that were misrouted as spam and 8.7% that were bounced.


The variation, such as it is, in e-mail reliability studies like these is almost certainly due to the fact that these consulting firms are measuring different mail streams. Each one has a client base that's used as a "test bed" to determine which e-mails get delivered to test accounts at which ISPs. Given that reality, it's remarkable that the latest three studies are as similiar as they are.

Michelle Eichner, vice president of client services for Pivotal Veracity, says these studies are a step toward gaining better reliability for corporations that now rely on e-mail to communicate with their customers.

"ISPs are forced to continue implementing new and different spam-filtering technology, which may not always be perfect," Eichner says. "We believe both 0% spam and 0% false positives will only be achieved through the joint efforts of the receiving and legitimate mailing community."

Here's a positive sign: One of the world's largest ISPs contacted Pivotal Veracity after last week's story appeared and asked how it can improve its delivery rate for permission-based e-mails, according to Eichner. Outreach like this might make e-mail a communications medium we can rely on once again.

Brian Livingston is the editor of and the coauthor of "Windows Me Secrets" and nine other books. Send story ideas to him via his contact page. To subscribe free and receive Executive Tech via e-mail, visit our signup page.

Executive Tech Archives

JupiterWeb networks:

Search JupiterWeb:

Jupitermedia Corporation has three divisions:

Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, & Permissions, Privacy Policy.

Jupitermedia Corporate Info | Newsletters | Tech Jobs | E-mail Offers